Mafia City
Crime melodrama in the ads, base building in the game
What the ads show. Crime melodrama with no relation to a strategy game: humiliation and revenge arcs, absurd criminal set pieces, characters in situations that make no sense in the context of the ad itself.
What the game is. A mafia-themed base-building MMO with alliances, resource management and troop training. Android package: com.yottagames.mafiawar.
Status. No ruling. Named repeatedly by the games press alongside Hero Wars and Project Makeover as a reference case for ads built on bizarre plots rather than gameplay. One outlet singled the Mafia City creatives out as its favourite example of the genre.
Note. The gap here is total: the ads do not show gameplay at all, so there is no mechanic to compare. That makes the case easy to describe and hard to quantify against the ASA's core gameplay test, which assumes the ad depicts something playable.